The following people each get a box of homemade chocolates:
- Alister
- (Radical) Edward
- Gamzee
- Link
- Serph
- Zack
- Zelos

The following get chocolates plus a more personalized gift:
- Darkleer - A Sleipnir pendant. Because Tifa still thinks of horses as eight-legged mythical creatures.
- Rin - A cookbook.
- Rinoa - Blue flower earrings.
- Sophie - The Knight and the Dragon.
- Vincent - A rhodonite pendant, and a note explaining she heard they were good for nightmares.

She'll be trying to give people their gifts in person, but if she can't track you down, she'll leave it outside your door for you to find.