- Axel - An instant camera and a stationery set (only in a manlier red).
- Chibiterasu - A large fruit basket.
- Demyx - A paopu fruit, along with an explanation of the legend.
- Hayner - An authentic Struggle bat.
- Kimblee - A red scarf and a note that says "Thanks for putting up with him."
- Link - A green Santa hat and a box of candy canes.
- Naminé - A moogle plushy.
- Riku - Oh, wait, you get nothing.
- Rin - A demon Christmas tree ornament, similar to this.
- Ruca - A thalassa charm.
- Selphie - A large box of assorted chocolates.
- Shirley - A blank journal.
- Sola - A red Santa hat and a box of candy canes.
- Sora - A handmade keychain and a water gun.
- Vanitas - A mended heart pillow and a box of salted dark chocolates.

Since he can get into anyplace he pleases, all gifts will be left in the characters' homes late Christmas Eve, under the tree if applicable. Vanitas's gifts will be left at Kimblee's.